Utilitarian board-gaming: higher and lower pleasures?
Page 1 of 1
Utilitarian board-gaming: higher and lower pleasures?
There's lots that can be said about the ethics of board-games: design, distribution, retail, re-sale and of course playing. A quick reflection and question on the last of those here for now:
One of the first problems in utilitarian ethics is that of defining desired ends, particularly when your starting point is pleasure or happiness*. The simplest utilitarian equation, given any decision, is to weigh total happiness vs total suffering resulting from each possibility and choose the best option. A slightly more complex approach is to weight different 'kinds' of pleasures differently - some being preferenced over others, either for individual or universal reasons. So, what types of pleasure or happiness do you derive from board games - and do you think some 'kinds' of board-game derived pleasure are higher than others?
Suggestions:
Schadenfreude - huge in some games, but I'm sure Rahdo would give it a negative rating. Trump would weigh this big big.
'Fun' - silly antics, tomfoolery, laughter. Non-cerebral, social pleasure. Pfft! Should this even count?
Ureka! - pleasure gained from finally understanding rules / mechanical advantages / systems / your opponent's winning strategy
Victory - the pure carnal pleasure of grinding enemies into dust (Ameritrash)
Victory - the pure emotional pleasure of not having to watch all your workers starve (Euro)
Escapist - the pleasure of knowing that your failures are only simulated
Nihilistic - the pleasure of choosing frivolousness over productive use of your time
Libertarian - pleasure gained from believing and revelling in the existence of choices within your control**
Completist - the pleasure of having finally played that game you bought at UKGE 4 years ago (aka the Paul special)
*https://waitbutwhy.com/table/the-experience-machine
**http://www.informationphilosopher.com/freedom/libertarianism.html
One of the first problems in utilitarian ethics is that of defining desired ends, particularly when your starting point is pleasure or happiness*. The simplest utilitarian equation, given any decision, is to weigh total happiness vs total suffering resulting from each possibility and choose the best option. A slightly more complex approach is to weight different 'kinds' of pleasures differently - some being preferenced over others, either for individual or universal reasons. So, what types of pleasure or happiness do you derive from board games - and do you think some 'kinds' of board-game derived pleasure are higher than others?
Suggestions:
Schadenfreude - huge in some games, but I'm sure Rahdo would give it a negative rating. Trump would weigh this big big.
'Fun' - silly antics, tomfoolery, laughter. Non-cerebral, social pleasure. Pfft! Should this even count?
Ureka! - pleasure gained from finally understanding rules / mechanical advantages / systems / your opponent's winning strategy
Victory - the pure carnal pleasure of grinding enemies into dust (Ameritrash)
Victory - the pure emotional pleasure of not having to watch all your workers starve (Euro)
Escapist - the pleasure of knowing that your failures are only simulated
Nihilistic - the pleasure of choosing frivolousness over productive use of your time
Libertarian - pleasure gained from believing and revelling in the existence of choices within your control**
Completist - the pleasure of having finally played that game you bought at UKGE 4 years ago (aka the Paul special)
*https://waitbutwhy.com/table/the-experience-machine
**http://www.informationphilosopher.com/freedom/libertarianism.html
systemsam- Dominant Species
- Posts : 654
Join date : 2015-05-16
Similar topics
» Board Gaming in Sheffield
» My board gaming shame...
» Future of board gaming
» Other board gaming clubs in the region.
» 24 Hour Board Gaming anyone? April 2018
» My board gaming shame...
» Future of board gaming
» Other board gaming clubs in the region.
» 24 Hour Board Gaming anyone? April 2018
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Fri 01 Sep 2023, 09:25 by DaveB
» The King's Dilemma
Tue 29 Aug 2023, 20:18 by WateryBob
» Tuesday 1st August - Bring and Buy
Tue 01 Aug 2023, 11:11 by SamVS
» Tuesday 25th July - University Arms
Sun 23 Jul 2023, 10:54 by RikTheChief
» Travelling Man Sale
Thu 13 Jul 2023, 09:46 by RikTheChief
» Napoleon's Triumph
Fri 30 Jun 2023, 22:03 by paulby
» Sunday 2nd July - Red Deer
Tue 27 Jun 2023, 10:15 by MattT
» Tuesday 27th June 23
Mon 26 Jun 2023, 11:03 by RikTheChief
» Tuesday 20th June - University Arms 7pm
Mon 19 Jun 2023, 12:34 by RikTheChief